Skip to main content

The Stop Rate Analyst's View

Thank you Dr.

RH

-----Original Message-----
From: Cordner, Gary [mailto:cordner@kutztown.edu]
Sent: Thursday, February 6, 2014 4:57 PM
To: Richard Hylton
Subject: RE: San Diego Stop Rates

Hi Richard -- I will have to go back and re-read my own report to refresh my memory. In general, though, the kinds of data that we had, and analysis that we did, can document whether there are disparities in stops (although the "baseline" or "benchmark" issue is still a challenge in a border and tourist city like San Diego, so precise measurement of disparity is not so easy). What is hardest to establish, or "prove", is why? My best recollection is that we said we couldn't explain whether the disparities we found were due to so-called racial profiling or something else. Almost everybody has an opinion about what might cause it. We just admitted that we didn't have the evidence to make any scientifically valid claims about what caused it in San Diego.

Gary

Gary Cordner
362 Old Main
Department of Criminal Justice
Kutztown University
Kutztown, PA 19530 (USA)
484-560-9123 (mobile)
Modern Policing Blog: http://gcordner.wordpress.com/ World Policing Blog: http://worldpolicing.wordpress.com/
________________________________________
From: Richard Hylton [rhylton@san.rr.com]
Sent: Thursday, February 06, 2014 7:34 PM
To: Cordner, Gary
Subject: San Diego Stop Rates

Dr. Cordner;

Around 12 years ago you, together with others, performed an analysis of Vehicle Stop data for the City of San Diego.

The issues that caused the need for data collection and analysis have re-emerged; perhaps with a vengeance. The results from San Diego’s 2013 data is not substantially different from what was reported in November 2002.<http://www.sandiego.gov/police/pdf/stoprpt.pdf>  My numeric analysis shows that Blacks and Hispanics continue to be given undue attention by San Diego’s finest and the denial persists. Your analysis has been put forward as evidence of lack of disparate enforcement of traffic laws, in spite of its age. Last week, the present Chief, William Lansdowne, speaking at a hastily called meeting of the Public Safety and Livable Communities Committee of the City Council, quoted the November 2 report’s<http://www.sandiego.gov/police/pdf/stoprpt.pdf> conclusion, said to be that there was no systemic racial profiling on the part of the SDPD.

It is not clear to me how specific groups, Blacks, Hispanics and Other, can experience vehicle stop rates that are a multiple of that experienced by Whites and Asians and for a conclusion such as yours to be reached.  I may be mistaken, but I could not find any supporting information that explained the disparity; certainly nothing persuasive.

I will appreciate your comments or explanation on the subject.

Thank you.

Sincerely;

Richard Hylton
13166 Jane Court
San Diego CA 92129



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Even More Fatally Flawed And Still Unfit for Purpose or The Great Distraction

Subject: RIPA Advisory Board – More Fatally Flawed and Still Unfit for Purpose   I wanted to wait until I came into possession of the actual 2025 Annual RIPA Report, before writing this, but I found myself between a rock and a hard place. My strongest motivator was fear; fear of reading a newspaper or web-account of the RIPA results or seeing a TV Broadcast that is ruled by lies and/or happy talk. I remember last year too well.  I also feared that, as was the case with the reports from the last few years, the RIPA Report, to which the press has early or immediate access, would not become available to me for several days.  Because of that, I decided to write this.   “Racial Discrimination is an inference that may be drawn from Racial Disparities.” In the absence of other inferences, or plausible explanations, our choices become limited.   There is an abundance of racial disparities to be found in RIPA data. I am unaware of any adverse disparity that has...
Post a Comment
Read more

Self-Inflicted Wounds are quite useful

April 6, 2014 Richard Hylton 13166 Jane Court San Diego, CA 92129 HyltonRichard@gmail.com By Email On the day that preceded the presentation of Vehicle Stop Data, by the SDPD, an email was circulated with this leading sentence. Update:   After reviewing the year-long   data   on race released by SDPD, there are major differences between what the   data   showed at 8 months versus at the end of 12 months. We don’t know why the numbers are so different (e.g. the number of stops per month fell significantly between January and December), but this underlines the need for a thorough, independent analysis of the   data   that can be communicated to the public. In light of this development, we have updated the ACLU’s comments below. The above was shocking and surprising, since it came from a writer who knew that a significant –some would say dramatic- fall-off in data collection rates had occurred in the fourth quarter. Evidence of the ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Deception

Background The United States Department of Justice has an opinion and position that is at odds with that of the San Diego Police Department. It holds that: "The guarantee to all persons of equal protection under the law is one of the most fundamental principles of our democratic society. Law enforcement officers should not endorse or act upon stereotypes, attitudes, or beliefs that a person’s race, ethnicity, or national origin increases that person’s general propensity to act unlawfully. There is no tradeoff between effective law enforcement and protection of the civil rights of all Americans; we can and must have both." In 2011, during litigation, Vehicle Stop data for the prior two years was sought. The City of San Diego, in sworn and other statements or filings, denied having any Vehicle Stop Data and convinced the court of that fact. In January 2013 I learned that the City had committed perjury. Following that I obtained and distributed Vehicle Stop...
Post a Comment
Read more