Skip to main content

Stop Skylarking

Disparity Index (ratio of stops to population%)
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records
%
Census
Disparity
%
Disparity
Index
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
16.99
0.50
50.03%
54.92%
Black              
16140
11.196
5.5
2.04
203.56%
223.48%
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
27.03
1.12
111.62%
122.55%
Other              
10292
7.139
3.23
2.21
221.02%
242.65%
White              
61981
42.993
47.2
0.91
91.09%
100.00%
Totals
144164
100
99.95
3.23
is unsound
1. Citations
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records
%
Cited
Cited%
Cited
ToStops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
6624
7.737
54.056
88.23
Black              
16140
11.196
7754
9.056
48.042
78.42
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
26631
31.104
61.225
99.94
Other              
10292
7.139
6639
7.754
64.506
105.29
White              
61981
42.993
37972
44.349
61.264
100.00
Totals
144164
100
85620
100
No articulable reason has been presented
2. Arrests
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records
%
Arrested
Arrested%
Arrests
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
2024
8.788
131
6.434
1.069
81.73
Black              
2143
9.305
303
14.882
1.877
143.50
Hispanic           
7435
32.283
707
34.725
1.625
124.24
Other              
1752
7.607
84
4.126
0.816
62.39
White              
9677
42.017
811
39.833
1.308
100.00
Totals
23031
100
2036
100
3. Consent Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records
%
Consent
Search
Consent
Search%
Consent
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
109
25.467
7.847
31.41
Black              
16140
11.196
370
21.958
26.638
106.63
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
532
18.408
38.301
153.31
Other              
10292
7.139
31
14.833
2.232
8.93
White              
61981
42.993
347
17.464
24.982
100.00
Totals
144164
100
1389
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records
%
Searched
Searched%
Searched
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
428
5.945
3.493
108.95
Black              
16140
11.196
1685
23.406
10.44
325.64
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
2890
40.144
6.644
207.24
Other              
10292
7.139
209
2.903
2.031
63.35
White               
61981
42.993
1987
27.601
3.206
100.00
Totals
144164
100
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records
%
Consent Search
Consent Search%
Consent
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
104
8.254
0.849
174.69
Black              
16140
11.196
343
27.222
2.125
437.24
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
485
38.492
1.115
229.42
Other              
10292
7.139
27
2.143
0.262
53.91
White              
61981
42.993
301
23.889
0.486
100.00
Totals
144164
100
1260
100
4. Contraband found
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Contra
band
Found
Contra-
band
Found%
Contraband
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
46
10.748
0.38
94.50
Black              
16140
11.196
119
7.062
0.74
62.09
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
202
6.99
0.46
61.46
Other              
10292
7.139
19
9.091
0.19
79.93
White              
61981
42.993
226
11.374
0.37
100.00
Totals
144164
100
612

5. Property Seized
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Property
Seized
Property
Seized%
Property
Seized
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
38
4.967
0.31
82.89
Black              
16140
11.196
128
16.732
0.793
212.03
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
347
45.359
0.798
213.37
Other              
10292
7.139
20
2.614
0.194
51.87
White              
61981
42.993
232
30.327
0.374
100.00
Totals
144164
100
765
99.999
6. Vehicle Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Vehicle
Search
Vehicle
Search%
Vehicle
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
237
5.438
1.934
105.68
Black              
16140
11.196
993
22.786
6.152
336.17
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
1874
43.001
4.308
235.41
Other              
10292
7.139
120
2.754
1.166
63.72
White              
61981
42.993
1134
26.021
1.83
100.00
Totals
144164
100
4358
100
7. Driver Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Driver
Search
Driver
Search%
Driver
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
229
7.404
1.869
132.55
Black              
16140
11.196
759
24.539
4.703
333.55
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
1150
37.181
2.644
187.52
Other              
10292
7.139
81
2.619
0.787
55.82
White              
61981
42.993
874
28.257
1.41
100.00
Totals
144164
100
3093
100
8. Passenger Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Passenger
Search
Passenger
Search%
Passenger
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian               
12254
8.5
44
5.767
0.359
104.97
Black              
16140
11.196
231
30.275
1.431
418.42
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
256
33.552
0.589
172.22
Other              
10292
7.139
20
2.621
0.194
56.73
White              
61981
42.993
212
27.785
0.342
100.00
Totals
144164
100
763
100
9. Nonconsensual Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Non-
Consent
Search
Non-
Consent
Search%
Non-
Consent
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
320
5.5
2.611
98.49
Black              
16140
11.196
1317
22.637
8.16
307.81
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
2360
40.564
5.426
204.68
Other              
10292
7.139
178
3.059
1.729
65.22
White              
61981
42.993
1643
28.24
2.651
100.00
Totals
144164
100
5818
100
10. Searches Incident to Arrest
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Search
Incident
To Arrest
Search
Incident
To Arrest%
Search
Incident
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
53
5.955
0.433
76.50
Black              
16140
11.196
127
14.27
0.787
139.05
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
328
36.854
0.754
133.22
Other              
10292
7.139
31
3.483
0.301
53.18
White              
61981
42.993
351
39.438
0.566
100.00
Totals
144164
100
890
100

11. Inventory Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Inventory
Search
Inventory
Search%
Inventory
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
74
3.719
0.604
72.51
Black              
16140
11.196
291
14.623
1.803
216.45
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
1042
52.362
2.396
287.64
Other              
10292
7.139
67
3.367
0.651
78.15
White              
61981
42.993
516
25.93
0.833
100.00
Totals
144164
100
1990
100.001
12. Fourth Waiver Searches
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
4th Waiver
 Search
4th Waiver
Search%
4thWaiver
Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
116
6.686
0.947
130.98
Black              
16140
11.196
616
35.504
3.817
527.94
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
515
29.683
1.184
163.76
Other              
10292
7.139
40
2.305
0.389
53.80
White              
61981
42.993
448
25.821
0.723
100.00
Totals
144164
100
1735
99.999
13.Field Interviews
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Field
Interview
Field
Interview
%
Field
Interview
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
411
8.407
3.354
173.69
Black              
16140
11.196
1600
32.727
9.913
513.36
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
1534
31.377
3.527
182.65
Other              
10292
7.139
147
3.007
1.428
73.95
White              
61981
42.993
1197
24.484
1.931
100.00
Totals
144164
100
4889*
100.002
14a. Field Interviews To Written Warning
Race
Category
Number
Population
Race
Percent
Percent
To Pop%
Selection String
Census
Year
Asian              
145
16.99
8.96
52.74
FI to WWarning          
2015
Black              
553
5.5
34.18
621.45
FI to WWarning          
2015
Hispanic           
509
27.03
31.46
116.39
FI to WWarning           
2015
Other              
57
3.23
3.52
108.98
FI to WWarning          
2015
White              
354
47.2
21.88
46.36
FI to WWarning          
2015
Totals:
1618
99.95
100
14b. Field Interviews To Verbal Warning
Race
Category
Number
Population
Race
Percent
Percent
To Pop%
Selection String
Census
Year
Asian              
4
16.99
10
58.86
FI to V.WWarning        
2015
Black              
11
5.5
27.5
500
FI to V.WWarning        
2015
Hispanic           
14
27.03
35
129.49
FI to V.WWarning        
2015
Other              
3
3.23
7.5
232.2
FI to V.WWarning        
2015
White              
8
47.2
20
42.37
FI to V.WWarning        
2015
Totals:
40
99.95
100
15. Search where odour of Contraband present
Race
Category
Stop
Records
Stop
Records%
Odor Of
Contra-band
Search
Odor Of
Contra-
band
Search%
Odor Of
Contra-
band Search
To Stops
Compared
To Whites
Asian              
12254
8.5
7
3.804
0.057
60.64
Black              
16140
11.196
60
32.609
0.372
395.74
Hispanic           
43497
30.172
54
29.348
0.124
131.91
Other              
10292
7.139
5
2.717
0.049
52.13
White              
61981
42.993
58
31.522
0.094
100.00
Totals
144164
100
184
100

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Even More Fatally Flawed And Still Unfit for Purpose or The Great Distraction

Subject: RIPA Advisory Board – More Fatally Flawed and Still Unfit for Purpose   I wanted to wait until I came into possession of the actual 2025 Annual RIPA Report, before writing this, but I found myself between a rock and a hard place. My strongest motivator was fear; fear of reading a newspaper or web-account of the RIPA results or seeing a TV Broadcast that is ruled by lies and/or happy talk. I remember last year too well.  I also feared that, as was the case with the reports from the last few years, the RIPA Report, to which the press has early or immediate access, would not become available to me for several days.  Because of that, I decided to write this.   “Racial Discrimination is an inference that may be drawn from Racial Disparities.” In the absence of other inferences, or plausible explanations, our choices become limited.   There is an abundance of racial disparities to be found in RIPA data. I am unaware of any adverse disparity that has...

Self-Inflicted Wounds are quite useful

April 6, 2014 Richard Hylton 13166 Jane Court San Diego, CA 92129 HyltonRichard@gmail.com By Email On the day that preceded the presentation of Vehicle Stop Data, by the SDPD, an email was circulated with this leading sentence. Update:   After reviewing the year-long   data   on race released by SDPD, there are major differences between what the   data   showed at 8 months versus at the end of 12 months. We don’t know why the numbers are so different (e.g. the number of stops per month fell significantly between January and December), but this underlines the need for a thorough, independent analysis of the   data   that can be communicated to the public. In light of this development, we have updated the ACLU’s comments below. The above was shocking and surprising, since it came from a writer who knew that a significant –some would say dramatic- fall-off in data collection rates had occurred in the fourth quarter. Evidence of the ...

Deception

Background The United States Department of Justice has an opinion and position that is at odds with that of the San Diego Police Department. It holds that: "The guarantee to all persons of equal protection under the law is one of the most fundamental principles of our democratic society. Law enforcement officers should not endorse or act upon stereotypes, attitudes, or beliefs that a person’s race, ethnicity, or national origin increases that person’s general propensity to act unlawfully. There is no tradeoff between effective law enforcement and protection of the civil rights of all Americans; we can and must have both." In 2011, during litigation, Vehicle Stop data for the prior two years was sought. The City of San Diego, in sworn and other statements or filings, denied having any Vehicle Stop Data and convinced the court of that fact. In January 2013 I learned that the City had committed perjury. Following that I obtained and distributed Vehicle Stop...